1988
- Lost 14-7 to Lima Bath in the Regional Semi-Final – played at Marion
1990
- Won 42-7 against Rossford in the Regional Semi-Final – played at Bellevue
- Lost 7-6 to Richfield Revere in the Regional Final – played at Berea
1999
- Won 13-0 against Bellevue in the Regional Quarter-Final – played at Bellevue
- Lost 33-27 to Columbus Bishop Watterson in the Regional Semi-Final – played at Marion
2001
- Won 27-7 against Bellefontaine in the Regional Quarter-Final – played at Bellefontaine
- Lost 24-22 to Big Walnut in the Regional Semi-Final – played at Marion
2002
- Won 42-21 against Medina Buckeye in the Regional Quarter-Final – played at Home
- Lost 47-21 to Akron Buchtel in the Regional Semi-Final – played at Wooster
2020
- Lost 37-12 to Indian Lake in 1st round – played at Lewistown